Fencer's Start-Up: A Beginner's Guide to Fencing (Start-Up Sports series)

But the author has no respect for the tradition of fencing, nor does he come off as being more than anything than a "Sport Fencer" and semi-literate jock who has nothing but his own glorification in mind when he writes.

The most intolerable and tedious part of this tome is the "Fencing Journal." I must applaud whoever his maestro was, because he must have had the patience of a saint to put up with the author's temper tantrums, disgraceful behavior and overall infantilism.

This book is asinine. I would highly recommend Nick Evangelista's books and BY THE SWORD by Cohen for a true sentiment de fer. Avoid this piece of garbage like the plague, or if you must sbject yourself, get it at the local library.


You All Miss The Point Of This Book...   May 25, 2001
 21 out of 23 found this review helpful

I checked this book out at a local library in Kansas City when I was looking for a book to help learn the basic skills of fencing. When I first read "Fencer's Start-Up: A Beginner's Guide To Traditional And Sport Fencing" I thought I had discovered at least a primer for the on-guard position, parries and basic attacks. Unfortunatly the descriptions of the body mechanics involved for the moves were to shallow for me to make use of them. I started reading the second half of the book and that is when the book redeemed itself.

The author included a short journal of his learning experiences as a fencer. He did manage to be honest throughout the entire journal and that's what makes the second half so good. Not a lot of author's can be totally honest with their readers when they sit down to write even a simple treatise on fencing. The manage to write themselves into a good light as with most short autobiographies but this author didn't.

You all came to this book expecting a serious manual on the art of fencing and I think that is the wrong attitude to approach this book with. Try to think of this book as a tool to get a young person passionate about the sport by showing them how simple a game it is to play. Most of the books on fencing I have read have a stern classical view of fencing, one that keeps it's full people potential chained back by tradition. What I mean is that most of the books I have read do not make fencing look like something that can be done by just anyone. They confine the sport to the rich, the elite or those who already have friends or family fencing. This books was a small attempt to change that by showing people the game without a great deal of tradition. For that it is a book I would want in my library.

For those of you who don't agree with what I have said I say, "Tough."


Unpretentious beginner's guide   March 27, 2001
 5 out of 5 found this review helpful

This is a lightweight introduction to fencing that deliberately avoids detailed technical explanation and historical background. The serious student should look elsewhere, but the book is intended more to spark interest in those who might otherwise be tempted to write off fencing as old fashioned, elitist and boring. 'Sport fencing' tries to combat this attitude. Mr. Werner's fencing diary is to be commended for its honesty, he does not always portray himself in the best of lights. For mature students starting out, or for instructors who want insight on how their students may see them, this part has value.